15 replies to this topic

[coolbrezze]

I read many people make comments on West Michigan or East Michigan. Although I find it hard to locate Lansing, Michigan between the two. Which would you consider Lansing, Michigan as?
( I hear many people say mid-Michigan when refferring to Lansing, although I would just like an explanation of west or east for this thread).

Edited by coolbrezze, 10 December 2008 - 07:51 PM.

[GRDadof3]

coolbrezze, on Dec 10 2008, 08:50 PM, said:

I read many people make comments on West Michigan or East Michigan. Although I find it hard to locate Lansing, Michigan between the two. Which would you consider Lansing, Michigan as?
( I hear many people say mid-Michigan when refferring to Lansing, although I would just like an explanation of west or east for this thread).

Mid-Michigan.  I think of West Michigan as about Ionia to the lakeshore, down to about Allegan, up to about Ludington or so.  East Michigan would be anything East of a line near Fowlerville/Howell area (about where I-96 turns into a six lane highway).  Southeast Michigan I think of as Oakland, Macomb, Wayne, Livingston and Washtenaw counties.

[OneSweetWorld]

You can't call something east or west when it's smack dab in the middle...

[suydam]

Lansing is neither East nor West.  It truly is mid-Michigan.

That said, I think it's more attached, culturally and economically to Detroit than Grand Rapids.  Not because that's good or bad per se... just because Detroit is the epicenter of everything Michigan, so a city located equidistant between the biggest and second biggest cities would generally relate more to it's biggest neighbor.

[LA Dave]

suydam, on Dec 17 2008, 06:29 PM, said:

Lansing is neither East nor West.  It truly is mid-Michigan.

That said, I think it's more attached, culturally and economically to Detroit than Grand Rapids.  Not because that's good or bad per se... just because Detroit is the epicenter of everything Michigan, so a city located equidistant between the biggest and second biggest cities would generally relate more to it's biggest neighbor.

I agree, Mid-Michigan.  I never thought of Lansing as West Michigan, geographically or culturally.  Too far from the Big Lake.

[tracer1138]

If you think of it in terms of enclaves or sub-communities, you might define your region as the network of places you and the people you know go frequently.  In that respect, growing up in West Michigan, when I think of it, I remember going to Grand Rapids, St. Joseph, Three Rivers, Holland, Grand Haven, South Haven...etc. prominently as being part of the experience of living in West Michigan, whereas I think of the very few times I've been to Lansing rather as being part of the experience of living in Michigan.  Also, this was the general area in which my high school traveled to compete in sports, etc. If and when we ever traveled to Lansing it was usually for some State-Level competition.

Edited by tracer1138, 19 December 2008 - 10:33 PM.

[coolbrezze]

LA Dave, on Dec 19 2008, 06:19 PM, said:

I agree, Mid-Michigan. I never thought of Lansing as West Michigan, geographically or culturally. Too far from the Big Lake.

Thanks for the reply's

Too far from the lake? I don't think Lansing, Michigan isn't that far from Lake Michigan at all, nor any other great lakes. It's a decent driving distance to all. Although since many may drive through a big city like Grand Rapids to get to lake Michigan, it may seem further.

[LA Dave]

coolbrezze, on Dec 20 2008, 10:23 AM, said:

Thanks for the reply's

Too far from the lake? I don't think Lansing, Michigan isn't that far from Lake Michigan at all, nor any other great lakes. It's a decent driving distance to all. Although since many may drive through a big city like Grand Rapids to get to lake Michigan, it may seem further.

Not a question of driving distance, it's a question of climate and of attitude.  In GR, the Big Lake was always a presence.  In the summer, it was a 30 minute drive to the beach.  In the winter, it meant snow day in and day out (the dreaded "lake effect.")  I don't think that's true about Lansing.  Sorry.  Too far from the Big Lake.

[coolbrezze]

Well as a resident of the area, I know many people who drive to Lake Michigan (or the other lakes) frequently during the summer weeks to enjoy the beach. Same for snow, we may not get lake effect snow all the time as those more west, but we experience it often.

[LA Dave]

coolbrezze, on Dec 21 2008, 05:42 PM, said:

Well as a resident of the area, I know many people who drive to Lake Michigan (or the other lakes) frequently during the summer weeks to enjoy the beach. Same for snow, we may not get lake effect snow all the time as those more west, but we experience it often.

Here's a question:  Do people in Lansing refer to Lake Michigan as "the Big Lake"?  If they don't they're not from West Michigan.

[coolbrezze]

LA Dave, on Dec 22 2008, 04:32 PM, said:

Here's a question: Do people in Lansing refer to Lake Michigan as "the Big Lake"? If they don't they're not from West Michigan.

Most people in Lansing refer to Lake Michigan as "Lake Michigan", although that goes for all those I know who stay on the west side of the state...... "the Big Lake" I'm sure it's use by some in the area, and for those on the west side of the state... just those I know/ run into on all sides of the state simply keeps it's name "Lake Michigan".

[LA Dave]

coolbrezze, on Dec 22 2008, 05:25 PM, said:

Most people in Lansing refer to Lake Michigan as "Lake Michigan", although that goes for all those I know who stay on the west side of the state...... "the Big Lake" I'm sure it's use by some in the area, and for those on the west side of the state... just those I know/ run into on all sides of the state simply keeps it's name "Lake Michigan".

Well, it's been a long time since I lived there, but when you said "the Big Lake" in Grand Rapids, everyone knew what you were referring to.  I doubt that is true in Lansing, which is as close to Lake Erie as it is to Lake Michigan.  

Sorry.  Lansing is NOT in West Michigan.  Never has been.  Never will be.  

It is in Mid-Michigan, a distinction it shares with Jackson, Owosso, Mt. Pleasant and a number of other fine communities.

[coolbrezze]

LA Dave, on Dec 22 2008, 10:05 PM, said:

Well, it's been a long time since I lived there, but when you said "the Big Lake" in Grand Rapids, everyone knew what you were referring to. I doubt that is true in Lansing, which is as close to Lake Erie as it is to Lake Michigan.

Sorry. Lansing is NOT in West Michigan. Never has been. Never will be.

It is in Mid-Michigan, a distinction it shares with Jackson, Owosso, Mt. Pleasant and a number of other fine communities.

Sorry for what? This thread is strictly opinionated.
Good, now that I got yours may the thread countinue.....

____________________________________________________
Never made a comment on whether Lansing is on the east or west side of Michigan, although due to it's location anyone can debate on that issue. Which brings to account why I made such a thread.

[OneSweetWorld]

LA Dave, on Dec 22 2008, 04:32 PM, said:

Here's a question:  Do people in Lansing refer to Lake Michigan as "the Big Lake"?  If they don't they're not from West Michigan.

I live in West Michigan and have never referred to Lake Michigan as the "Big Lake." More just "the beach." Although I would know what one is talking about if he or she said "big lake."

[vompy]

I agree ^

[Yankee Fan]

I have always referred to it as "The Big Lake."  

But I would make a note that I hear the "Big Lake" terminology being used more consistently among those in the West Michigan boating community.  As a boater, I hear things like "Do you want to stay inland or go the The Big Lake?" or "I was out on "The Big Lake."

Edited by Yankee Fan, 18 March 2009 - 12:46 PM.