Aporkalypse, on Nov 2 2006, 09:54 PM, said:
Interesting. I'm not a big fan of 300 Third and thought it didn't fit the area nearly as well as the building they tore down to build it. This project seems to be a hybrid between the red brick warehouses and a modern design that I thought would work really well, especially incorporating it into one development with Tuf-Nut. This building utilizes ground level retail and creates a pedestrian-friendly streetscape much better than 300 Third in my opinion.
Then again, I'm no architect.
Aporkalypse - you are certainly entitled to your opinion, as this is mine. But - if I may borrow from my own post on 300 Third - it is a modern, sophisticated tower that creates a healthy juxtaposition with the surrounding context - very well executed. To me (and many others) it looks great. It says "Hey, I was actually built in 2007!" and doesn't make any apology to it, which is how it should be. You don't have to resort to knee-jerk, knock-off "traditional" cliches, which never live up to the spirit of the original craftsmanship anyway. Textbook example - First Security Center.
My first reaction to the Rivermarket Tower is that it is quite bland - as is its name. I hope its just a poor rendering, and that the actual design proves a little more sophisticated - and I have hopes that it will (it could be that the materials match 300 Third - the rendering technique is altogether different though, which makes me question if this is an AMR project).
I shouldn't give full judgement off of one drawing. However, the original 300 Third rendering had a tremendous "wow" factor that this does not. It really does look like an "uh-oh" child of Capital Commerce (shape) and First Security (exterior materials/aesthetics). I guess I was also expecting it to be measurably taller than 19 stories, but it is by no means insignificant.
However, I do agree that the pedestrian scale, mixed-use planning of that whole block for Rivermarket Tower is a plus. This is a good thing. I like the fact that it fills the block, reinforcing the urban edge - with retail no less!
This post has been edited by Architect: 02 November 2006 - 11:11 PM