Guest 5th & Main Urbanite

Federal Courthouse

Recommended Posts


BnaBreaker    4595

So when this is done the design, which looked outdated by 28 years when it was first released, will be 28 years old. So exciting!

Edited by BnaBreaker
  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
markhollin    19339

From today's Nashville Post:

The federal government is targeting an early 2021 opening for its downtown Nashville courthouse, Nashville Business Journal reports.

Quoting U.S. District Court Judge Aleta Trauger, NBJ reports demolition looms for a vacant five-story office building located at the northeast corner of Church Street and Eighth Avenue South. Environmental sample work is slated for Sept. 23, NBJ reports. A parking garage sitting within the footprint also will need razing.

The U.S. General Services Administration, which is overseeing the project, will request bids for various work and is hoping to award the design and construction contracts next year, according to NBJ.

The historic Berger Building that fronts Eighth will remain.

The project is expected to carry a price tag of $167.4 million.
 

Sounds as if the design is not finalized.  Would seem after all these years that there might be some significant modifications, if not out-and-out redesign. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
bmkTN    228

Yeah I noticed that too.  Interesting.

6 minutes ago, markhollin said:

 

Sounds as if the design is not finalized.  Would seem after all these years that there might be some significant modifications, if not out-and-out redesign. 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

donNdonelson2    2012

I heard the new design would be inspired by this classical/modern mixup.:tw_confounded:

 

(oh please, all that is holy, don't let it be any worse than what we've seen in previous proposals!)

image.jpeg

 

Edited by donNdonelson2
Remove double post of text

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
markhollin    19339

More info from Tennessean: "Katmai Support Services of Smyrna will handle demolition services under the roughly $1.8 million contract that the U.S. General Services Administration announced on Wednesday." (Markhollin: I've heard this will start very soon).

"A joint venture of Michael Graves and Associates Inc. and Thomas Miller & Partners LLC are handling design services for the new U.S. Courthouse project under a $3.2 million contract that was awarded in July.  Upon completion of concept design by March, the General Services Administration will conduct a competition to award a design-build contract with that winner to complete the design and construction."

http://www.tennessean.com/story/money/real-estate/2016/09/21/demolition-make-way-194m-new-nashville-federal-courthouse/90779072/

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
titanhog    6402
4 hours ago, markhollin said:

More info from Tennessean: "Katmai Support Services of Smyrna will handle demolition services under the roughly $1.8 million contract that the U.S. General Services Administration announced on Wednesday." (Markhollin: I've heard this will start very soon).

"A joint venture of Michael Graves and Associates Inc. and Thomas Miller & Partners LLC are handling design services for the new U.S. Courthouse project under a $3.2 million contract that was awarded in July.  Upon completion of concept design by March, the General Services Administration will conduct a competition to award a design-build contract with that winner to complete the design and construction."

http://www.tennessean.com/story/money/real-estate/2016/09/21/demolition-make-way-194m-new-nashville-federal-courthouse/90779072/

So...sounds like it could be 100% different than the current render?

  • Like 4

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
PHofKS    3657
9 hours ago, markhollin said:

"A joint venture of Michael Graves and Associates Inc. and Thomas Miller & Partners LLC are handling design services for the new U.S. Courthouse project under a $3.2 million contract that was awarded in July.  Upon completion of concept design by March, the General Services Administration will conduct a competition to award a design-build contract with that winner to complete the design and construction."
 

Michael Graves (deceased) was the original designer, so it sounds to me like the firm he founded may not necessarily stray too far from one of the three rendered iterations revealed over the past few years. The word 'design' has several applications in the construction world including connection with phrases such as architectural design, engineering design, and construction design (preparation of critical path charts, scheduling of construction phases, etc.).  So, design-build may mean in this case that the floor plans, elevations and some materials are presented and the builder decides how best to schedule and build the structural aspects of the building per general specifications. Thomas Miller may be only the local architects assigned with the construction management aspects of the project (i.e. bidding, bid documents, inspection, payments, plans changes, etc.).

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

PruneTracy    887
8 hours ago, PHofKS said:

Michael Graves (deceased) was the original designer, so it sounds to me like the firm he founded may not necessarily stray too far from one of the three rendered iterations revealed over the past few years. The word 'design' has several applications in the construction world including connection with phrases such as architectural design, engineering design, and construction design (preparation of critical path charts, scheduling of construction phases, etc.).  So, design-build may mean in this case that the floor plans, elevations and some materials are presented and the builder decides how best to schedule and build the structural aspects of the building per general specifications. Thomas Miller may be only the local architects assigned with the construction management aspects of the project (i.e. bidding, bid documents, inspection, payments, plans changes, etc.).

Here's the RFP (the GSA sole-sourced it, so no detailed scope of work):

https://www.fbo.gov/index?s=opportunity&mode=form&tab=core&id=bff9a91871a175315ea79689b129bc4f

It sounds like the team is serving as a bridging architect so it's entirely possible the design-build teams come out with a completely different design (in terms of the architectural look of the building; massing, orientation, space planning, etc. will be determined by the bridging architect). On the other hand this procurement method implies GSA is going to try to do it on the cheap so I wouldn't expect any miracles.

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree there will be no architectural wonder created. I do have a question, why does "this procurement method"  lead you to conclude they will do the project on the cheap? Does the government not normally use this method? I saw where the project cost is now close to $200,000,000.... I hope that can buy a building with some architectural credibility. - Thanks

 

1 hour ago, PruneTracy said:

Here's the RFP (the GSA sole-sourced it, so no detailed scope of work):

https://www.fbo.gov/index?s=opportunity&mode=form&tab=core&id=bff9a91871a175315ea79689b129bc4f

It sounds like the team is serving as a bridging architect so it's entirely possible the design-build teams come out with a completely different design (in terms of the architectural look of the building; massing, orientation, space planning, etc. will be determined by the bridging architect). On the other hand this procurement method implies GSA is going to try to do it on the cheap so I wouldn't expect any miracles.

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
markhollin    19339

From today's Tennessean:

"Nashville's planned new federal courthouse is expected to rise five stories tall and occupy roughly 339,000 square feet of space, according to the U.S. General Services Administration. A former state office building at 719 Church St. is expected to be demolished between Dec. 26 and Jan. 13 to make way for the $194 million project. The General Services Administration recently awarded Katmai Support Services a roughly $1.8 million demolition services contract. Concept design should be completed in March for the courthouse building, which is expected to be completed in spring 2021."

Since the ceilings in courtrooms are normally around 16-20 feet in height, it would be safe to say that this will appear to be more like 10 stories tall.  The previous rendering had it at about 6 stories, and roughly 400,000 sq. ft., on top of a garage pedestal of sorts.  My guess is there are going to be some revisions, if not complete overhaul, of the design.

This is the former TennCare Building at 719 Church Street that will demolished very soon, along with the old parking garage facing 7th Avenue:

 

Former TennCare offices at  719 Church.JPG

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Nashtitans    1244

^damn thats an ugly building. Hope the courthouse actually gets a good design (doubt it knowing the track record of this city) but i still hold hope.

 

And 2021?? 5 years of construction, is that needed for a 5 story building?

Edited by Nashtitans
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
kc8501    115
2 hours ago, Nashtitans said:

^damn thats an ugly building. Hope the courthouse actually gets a good design (doubt it knowing the track record of this city) but i still hold hope.

 

And 2021?? 5 years of construction, is that needed for a 5 story building?

It is when you're talking about the government doing something! 

  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Neigeville2    829
12 hours ago, Nashtitans said:

^damn thats an ugly building...

Actually the two sides that face the street have a rather handsome modernist facade, brutal but with hints of classicism in the heavy (granite?) base, columnar ornamentation and fenestrated crown, like fascist architecture.  It's like Mussolini's version of the DMV.  One can easily imagine red black and white swastikas embedded at the tops of the outer columns.

tncare_zpsc6tc3gce.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
rookzie    2254
43 minutes ago, Neigeville2 said:

Actually the two sides that face the street have a rather handsome modernist facade, brutal but with hints of classicism in the heavy (granite?) base, columnar ornamentation and fenestrated crown, like fascist architecture.  It's like Mussolini's version of the DMV.  One can easily imagine red black and white swastikas embedded at the tops of the outer columns.

I'm thinking that the base actually might be terrazzo slab tiles, rather than granite.  When I walked by the thing a few years ago, before the scaffolding got erected, the finish gave me the impression of a milled and polished cementitious composite.  And BTW, I believe that the scaffolding was put up on the decorative sides of the buildings facing Church St. and Rosa Parks Blvd., because at least one of those tiles became totally separated from the rusted metal lath and any other clad-anchoring and eventually fell to the sidewalk in the not-too-distant past.  I don't believe that anyone got hurt though.  That's likely the only reason that the protection would been applied when it was.

Tenn-Care_ex-Gold_&_Silver_nee-Sears_Nashville_deteriorated_facing..jpg

Edited by rookzie
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
rookzie    2254

Of course, back during the first half of last century, Memphis had been a much larger commercial and industrial base scale than had Nashville, as this Forum has discussed in the past.  Accordingly, the Sears, Roebuck, and Company had developed a much larger and unmistakably more grand structure in Memphis, compared to Church Street building in Nashville, which Sears had only leased as part of a 20-year contract by its builder, until it occupied its then-new department store in 1956 at LaFayette St. and Seventh Ave South.  Memphis and Nashville each had entirely purposes for their respective Sears facility.  While Nashville's Sears of was simply a retail store, in contrast, the Memphis operation (Sears Crosstown Distribution Center) was conceived as both a catalog order plant and retail store.

While not really relevant to this discussion, and without too much digression from the topic on-hand, the Memphis former Sears, which the city would have razed as late as 10 years ago, had the city not been so cash-strapped, fortunately and finally appears to be undergoing a massive, dramatic  re-purposing and redevelopment as a mixed-use urban village called "Crosstown Concourse", which also is to include a YMCA - Health Center partnership, as well as a 450-seat theater serving as home for the Memphis Symphony Orchestra. 

There actually is no fair comparison between the former Sears of Nashville and Memphis, and then I myself certainly will not miss the eyesore on Church St., which indeed has had structural (sinking foundation) issues for decades.


Former Sears Crosstown distribution center of Memphis, being transformed into "Crosstown Concourse"

Memphis Sears to include 450-seat theater as home of Memphis Symphony Orchestra.jpg

Edited by rookzie
  • Like 3

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.