HankStrong

I4 - Beyond the Ultimate [Pre-construction]

Recommended Posts

Of all the politicians I’ve known, Rick Scott is truly the most like a Bond villain. He cares for nothing but money.

As much as I dislike The Donald, he is at least human. He may only care about his tribe but at least he cares about someone.

Rick Scott is just completely and totally amoral. His only reason for existence is to make more money for himself no matter who or what gets run over in the process.

Even the Frists at HCA figured that out at the end and they are hardly the definition of warm and fuzzy themselves.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites


4 hours ago, JFW657 said:

Florida did, for awhile, give a lot of tax breaks and other financial incentives to the motion picture industry and we were getting a good bit of that business as well as other parts of the entertainment industry it attracted. But then, because Rick whatsizface (Governor Skeletor) and his cronies in the legislature didn't like the idea of those entertainment industry lib'rul types plying their anti-conservative values in our state, because it didn't jibe with their vision of Florida as a red state bastion of God-fearin', gun-totin', Republican-votin' straight-shooters, they put an end to those tax breaks and chased a very lucrative industry that was providing a lot of high paying jobs, both directly and indirectly via the ripple effect, out of our state and straight up to Georgia and other neighboring states, who welcomed them with open arms and plenty of incentives, and are now reaping the economic benefits the morons who run this state felt they were too good for. But listen to them talk, and they'll tell you all about how great they've been for Florida. 

I think its terrible that states and municipalities feel they need to throw money at these businesses that people like to see, that are hugely profitable without it and have no need for it. Every time they're given a tax incentive, that means others have to pay more to make up for them not paying. The movie jobs are the worst, since they are all temporary by their very nature. If taxes are too high for these businesses to consider Florida, we need to re-evaluate what our taxes are for all businesses and make it make sense without sweetheart deals, whether its too conservative or liberal groups. (I say tax churches, tax the movie studios, tax everyone, but at a much lower rate then we do today, so that way there is some sense of fairness)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Florida did, for awhile, give a lot of tax breaks and other financial incentives to the motion picture industry and we were getting a good bit of that business as well as other parts of the entertainment industry it attracted. But then, because Rick whatsizface (Governor Skeletor) and his cronies in the legislature didn't like the idea of those entertainment industry lib'rul types plying their anti-conservative values in our state, because it didn't jibe with their vision of Florida as a red state bastion of God-fearin', gun-totin', Republican-votin' straight-shooters, they put an end to those tax breaks and chased a very lucrative industry that was providing a lot of high paying jobs, both directly and indirectly via the ripple effect, out of our state and straight up to Georgia and other neighboring states, who welcomed them with open arms and plenty of incentives, and are now reaping the economic benefits the morons who run this state felt they were too good for. But listen to them talk, and they'll tell you all about how great they've been for Florida. 

It’s worth noting that much of the Orlando TV/film production dried up because incentives were eliminated, but there are other forces at play in some cases, namely internal corporate turmoil.

To use one of the examples another poster mentioned above, Nick Studios didn’t leave because they lost subsidies to film in Florida at USF, they left because corporate leadership churned and they didn’t see the value in filming there when other, more traditional studios existed in other parts of the country within the Viacom machine. Viacom is not an attractions entertainment company, they’re a content company so it was probably a little of, “what do we do with this weird hybrid studio/attraction?”

They also didn’t see the long game in their B2B relationship with Universal. Maybe it would have meant sticking it out on the backlot a little longer, but that would have given themselves and Universal time to figure out how to fold Nick more significantly into the parks in the future.

That’s just one example, but the timing of it all means this example gets lumped in with the broader narrative that production left due to incentives drying up. In fact, that had little to do with it at all.
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
47 minutes ago, orlandoguy said:

That’s just one example, but the timing of it all means this example gets lumped in with the broader narrative that production left due to incentives drying up. In fact, that had little to do with it at all.

While it's certainly true that other factors were involved, to say that lack of incentives "had little to do with it at all" is a quite an exaggeration.

From Florida Today:

Quote

 

No state incentives mean fewer films, TV shows made in Florida

https://www.floridatoday.com/story/news/local/2017/02/24/no-state-incentives-mean-fewer-films-tv-shows-made-florida/98316384/

As part of a promotional effort for the Oscar-nominated, space-themed film "Hidden Figures," its stars and others connected with the movie visited Kennedy Space Center in December.

But the irony is that no scenes from the film were shot at KSC — or anywhere else on the Space Coast, for that matter — except for historic stock footage.

Space Coast Film Commissioner Bonnie King said people connected with the film had contacted her to talk about locations for filming on the Space Coast. But, largely because Florida no longer offers incentives for film and television productions, "the higher-ups decided not to film here."

Instead, much of "Hidden Figures" was shot in Atlanta and other locations in Georgia, a state that has "fantastic film incentives" that make it attractive to shoot movies there, King said. Those incentives include transferable tax credits for the film productions.

John Lux, is the executive director of the film, television and digital-media industry trade association Film Florida.

Film Florida estimates that Brevard County's economy lost $10 million because "Hidden Figures" was shot in Georgia, rather than the Space Coast.

Two other big local losses that Film Florida cites:

$25 million because the television series "The Astronaut Wives Club" was shot in Louisiana and Mississippi, rather than the Space Coast. The 2015 series — which ran for 10 episodes before being canceled — focused on the wives of the original "Mercury 7" astronauts.

King said the beaches near Gulfport, Mississippi, were used to as a stand-in for Cocoa Beach.

$16 million because the proposed television series "Cocoa Beach" was not put into production, which King said was partly because of the lack of incentives. King said "Cocoa Beach" was to be based on a book by NBC space correspondent Jay Barbree called "Live From Cape Canaveral."

"In the last three-plus years, Florida has lost more than 50 film and TV projects that wanted to come to Florida, but were not able to because of the lack of a funded program," Lux said. "Those projects would have spent more than $875 million in Florida and used more than 140,000 hotel room nights."

King said the economic losses are not only the salaries of film crew that might be hired locally, but also could include such things as the renting of hotel rooms, the hiring of construction workers to build sets, and the hiring of caterers to feed the cast and crew.

Lux said the decision of the producers of the HBO football-focused television series "Ballers" to leave South Florida for California was primarily based on the end of incentives from Florida. He said the decision is costing Florida is more than $20 million in spending per production season, more than 2,800 Florida jobs, more than 1,000 hotel room nights per season and another 3,000 nights of condo/short-term rental uses per season.

 

Way to go, Skeletor. :thumbsup:

Way to put your strident, ideological purity ahead of the economic good of the state you were supposed to be working for the good of.

  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Rick Scott is a crook, but paying rich people to film in our areas for temporary "jobs" is not exactly a fantastic long-term economic plan, either. 

I like our beaches just fine without the additional exploitation. 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@JFW - Reading it again, my wording is somewhat oblique. When I said the State film incentives had little to do with it at all, I was referencing Nick Studios leaving the Universal back lot, not the larger pull out of film production in Florida in general.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, dcluley98 said:

Rick Scott is a crook, but paying rich people to film in our areas for temporary "jobs" is not exactly a fantastic long-term economic plan, either. 

I like our beaches just fine without the additional exploitation. 

But it's not just "paying rich people to film in our areas". 

It affects other industries and local businesses as well, who privide services to that industry.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ripple_effect

Should we also say construction "jobs" shouldn't be valued either, given their always temporary nature. 

The thing is, that when one temporary job ends, another one soon begins or has already begun and is hiring. One could earn a good, steady income for years working at these temporary "jobs". 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
19 minutes ago, JFW657 said:

But it's not just "paying rich people to film in our areas". 

It affects other industries and local businesses as well, who privide services to that industry.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ripple_effect

Should we also say construction "jobs" shouldn't be valued either, given their always temporary nature. 

The thing is, that when one temporary job ends, another one soon begins or has already begun and is hiring. One could earn a good, steady income for years working at these temporary "jobs". 

We also never know what kind of spinoffs will emerge to grow our economy. 

Simulation wasn’t a thing for either Martin in 1957 or WDW in 1971, but the presence of those two companies led to our major east-side job creator years later. It’s an industry in which Orlando is now recognized as a leader.

Meanwhile, the chip industry that was going to be the key to our future, disappeared almost as fast as it took to build a huge facility for it off JYP.

It has been pointed out that, “Hollywood didn’t make LA - aerospace did. Hollywood made Los Angeles INTERESTING.”

Cities like Atlanta, Nashville and Austin have all used entertainment successfully  to give them the “it” factor that helped them stand out from their peer cities.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, JFW657 said:

But it's not just "paying rich people to film in our areas". 

It affects other industries and local businesses as well, who privide services to that industry.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ripple_effect

Should we also say construction "jobs" shouldn't be valued either, given their always temporary nature. 

The thing is, that when one temporary job ends, another one soon begins or has already begun and is hiring. One could earn a good, steady income for years working at these temporary "jobs". 

I'm not saying we shouldn't value economic activity or temporary jobs. Any job is a good job to somebody looking for work. 

I am saying we should not be subsidizing these "job creators" at the expense of other things. There is a cost to everything. And Costs ~= $

Costs may be time, suffering, maintenance, traffic, pollution, worry, etc. 

Defining the costs and benefits of everything and trying to find efficiency is paramount to knowing what is really happening. Capitalism likes to maximize profits and ignore the undefined costs.

It is an inefficient method. I don't think we should be in the business of paying cash subsidies for initiating more temporary jobs while ignoring the other inherent costs/benefits that may occur from this activity. 

Sometimes no activity is a better activity. 

Edited by dcluley98

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, dcluley98 said:

I'm not saying we shouldn't value economic activity or temporary jobs. Any job is a good job to somebody looking for work. 

I am saying we should not be subsidizing these "job creators" at the expense of other things. There is a cost to everything. And Costs ~= $

Costs may be time, suffering, maintenance, traffic, pollution, worry, etc. 

Defining the costs and benefits of everything and trying to find efficiency is paramount to knowing what is really happening. Capitalism likes to maximize profits and ignore the undefined costs.

It is an inefficient method. I don't think we should be in the business of paying cash subsidies for initiating more temporary jobs while ignoring the other inherent costs/benefits that may occur from this activity. 

Sometimes no activity is a better activity. 

Well I'm not talking about just handing them wads of cash (or wads of checks) either.

I'm talking about tax breaks and eliminating various permit requirements, and the elimination or reduction of various fees and charges, etc,  that together, add up to quite an increase in production costs for them. 

Like when cities give similar tax breaks and incentives to big developers to put up high rise buildings or when counties give tax breaks and incentives to theme parks to build attractions or corporations to build manufacturing plants, etc, etc.

That's just the way the game is played.

Florida should right now have a growing and thriving film industry. We should occasionally be seeing film crews set up around downtown and elsewhere, shooting scenes for major TV shows and movies. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, JFW657 said:

Well I'm not talking about just handing them wads of cash (or wads of checks) either.

I'm talking about tax breaks and eliminating various permit requirements, and the elimination or reduction of various fees and charges, etc,  that together, add up to quite an increase in production costs for them. 

Like when cities give similar tax breaks and incentives to big developers to put up high rise buildings or when counties give tax breaks and incentives to theme parks to build attractions or corporations to build manufacturing plants, etc, etc.

That's just the way the game is played.

Florida should right now have a growing and thriving film industry. We should occasionally be seeing film crews set up around downtown and elsewhere, shooting scenes for major TV shows and movies. 

Rick Scott was pro eliminating permitting requirements, fees, and charges that you are talking about, he was only against eliminating direct tax breaks and incentives and handing them wads of cash. Its the same argument made by sports teams like the Magic, that the players and supporting staff are highly paid, good jobs, it makes lots of jobs for the difficult to employ as event staff... and your money will be well spent making temporary construction jobs, so you should give a half a billion dollars towards building a stadium that we won't pay adequate rent for. There will be a star arena in the city (that will be beat out by the next city being asked for the same thing next year)... when thats just giving Richard DeVos a half a billion dollars. I'm glad Orlando City showed they could do it the right way. Sports teams aren't just going to abandon the Florida market if the state doesn't give incentives. There are still several films being shot in Florida as well. Sure, it'd be more if we handed out money, but Florida doesn't exactly have a high unemployment rate right now anyways. We don't need to hand out money, or give them tax breaks that means some other Floridian is going to have to pay instead of that out of state firm.

Edited by aent
  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
32 minutes ago, HankStrong said:

Just a reminder that there is a politics thread.

Don’t be messin’ with Hank’s thread or he’ll throw one of those brise stones at ya!

To his point, we do have a thread for LOCAL and Florida politics in the Coffee House as well as the “Just Wow” thread to exercise your fevered MAGA fantasies (pro or con) as well as anything else that’s on your mind.

The challenge of course is that everything happening in transportation (at least at the state level) is tied up in political ideology.

This isn’t new - whether to use tolls or tax-based funds was widely debated regarding the  interstate system during the Eisenhower administration (and in fact goes back to debates between the Whigs and Jacksonian Democrats in the 1800s). The transit debate is covering much the same ground.

Let’s all try and do better and keep our OCD folks from a complete meltdown. I’m committed to keep trying!

 

Edited by spenser1058

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Fair point.  They are inbred.

 

My only thing is that we're here with diverse opinions, but we're all focused on making our metro better.  Politics just divide to an extreme degree.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By KJHburg
      Just went by the new RiverLights development off River Rd south of Wilmington. This is a great new master planned community over 1400 acres and with river access. They are building a great restaurant building right on the river and will have boardwalks and parks along the river. Plus there is some retail with apartments or condos above. Del Webb has started their age restricted community already in the community and I think other model homes are opening soon. Looks like a great new community. Could not find a master plan of it anywhere so if you know of one share it. Here is there webpage for the community http://www.riverlightsliving.com/




    • By pumphandle
      It looks like someone has created a Van Atta Connector page on wikipedia, but it's in danger of deletion within a few days if it can't be improved:
       
      https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Van_Atta_Connector
       
      I was sure that I had read about this before, but on searching the web for good sources, I came up surprisingly dry. Can somebody who follows this stuff edit that page to link out to a source or two, then remove the prime-for-deletion tag?
       
      Thanks in advance.
    • By US75Guy
      This article is several months old but gives a nice overview of the current project on I-25.   I kind of laugh at the "July 2013" completion date as I'm not sure they even have a chance of completion before the end of the year - but miracles can happen, right?
       
      http://www.bizjournals.com/denver/print-edition/2012/09/28/santa-fei-25-bridges-in-midst-of.html?page=all
       
             
    • By ucabear09
      Anyone have an idea what they're building behind the StudioPlus hotel at the intersection of Kanis Rd and Shackleford Rd? The lot was wooded but they have cleared it off and have put down a gravel base. Thanks!
    • By andremurra
      Statesboro seems to be bouncing back for some industry sectors - particularly multi-family construction as four major projects are now underway. One project is currently under construction, while three others are slated to begin construction in 2012. Hopefully these new projects will provide a multiplier effect for other industries to benefit as well. Several things have probably contributed to these new development - Georgia Southern University's explosive growth is definitely one obvious factor as the school has surpassed the 20,000 enrollment mark. Other local colleges have also surpasses previous enrollment records including East Georgia College which is currently building a new campus in Statesboro, as well as Ogeechee Technical College which is likely looking at major expansion soon as well (I understand they have broken their previous enrollment records).

      The Forum - 780 bedrooms - is a luxury apartment complex by Boca-Raton based Parkland Development Corporation currently under construction in on Old Register Road. The complex will feature 1/1, 2/2, 3/3, and 4/4 bedroom/bathroom layouts. This complex is obviously geared towards students and is expected to open in Summer 2012.

      I don't know much about The Monarch Douglas - 450 bedrooms, except that the name is very strange in my opinion.

      The Varsity Lodge - 500 bedrooms - sounds exciting to me because they will be demolishing a worn-down complex with the same name and rebuilding new 4-story units in the same location. Out with the old and in with the new. The current blighted property was foreclosed for good reason considering its terrible dis-repaired conditions. Personally, I think the location is the residences is a bit odd and would rather it be used for something else as its off the beaten path, but for the sake of density, I can complain.

      Aspen Heights - 800 bedrooms - sounds like its going to be a hott sprawled out mess, and future blight property from the layout as I understand it. I have not looked into this property (and I will later) but it seems like a terrible design just considering its dimensions. From what I understand there will be 213 separate buildings consisting of 2, 3, and 4 bedroom units - ughh.


      Other developments for Statesboro include a new Hampton Inn locating in the Market District. Some leaders are trying to create a TAD near the interstate for a new industrial park. There seems to be some undisclosed major development occurring on one of the already-congested highways. Georgia Southern is also getting a New York Pizzaria - Im not sure if that is a generic working name or the actual name of the eatery.