Jump to content

Should Cities Invest in Major League Sports?


monsoon

Should Cities Invest in Major League Sports?  

217 members have voted

  1. 1. Should cities spend tax money to build stadiums and arenas for the major league sports?

    • No
      71
    • Yes
      134
    • No Opinion
      11


Recommended Posts

Is it good policy for a city to invest tax money in building stadiums and arenas for major league sports? Specifically I mean the NFL, NBA, MLB and NHL.

Supporters for these venues always claim these are economic generators for the cities and in many cases they are built in downtowns and center cities in hopes they will bring some kind of revival in street life and build an urban fabric that people will want to visit and live in. So the question is, do they accomplish this goal or do they amount to little more than corporate welfare?

Link to comment
Share on other sites


  • Replies 80
  • Created
  • Last Reply

That's a good question esp. for cities like Grand Rapids, MI. My home town has the numbers to support a major sports team. But the process of aquiring one is not easy and very expencive. Added to that there are other things I'd like to see done in GR such as a new ampitheater to catch the big summer shed tours, a new PAC to take pressure off of our existing performnace hall, install a BRT or light rail system as our current bus system is taking on a record number of riders among other things. However, the economic impact a major sport team in GR would ripple across this city and region. But due to the cost of bringing in a big team, the risks are enormous. Thus, its an issue that would have to be pondered on very carefully.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would say its a good investment if the city would actually get a percentage of actual revenues from these arenas/stadiums. Then I could see a realistic point to front tax revenue for these stadiums.

Some of the newer stadiums can reach upwards to $400M, if not more. If its going to be tax money, use it on education, infrastructure, etc that have a long term effect on the entire community rather then those that just enjoy sports.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

New stadiums can be a great way for a city to kick off revitalization of a underutilized section of town, hopefully downtown area. However, that said, certain "agreements" made between cities and teams can be very detrimental to the municipality. This can be a good thing, but everything needs to be reviewed with a fine tooth comb.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Having a major league sports franchise is almost as important as having a Fortune 500 company located in your city or metro area. Cities bend over for both, which I don't necessarily agree with. However, I would not want to see the Twins, Wild, Vikings, or the T-Wolves leave for the simple fact that I like having the options. Therefore, I'm willing to pay and as a resident of Minneapolis, I'm happy that the new Twins stadium will be opening in 2010.

Downtown Minneapolis can expect nothing but good things from having a new stadium.

* A new transit hub under the stadium that will connect the Hiawatha light-rail line and North Star commuter line.

* Between 3,000 and 5,000 units of housing are planned around the stadium

* New shops, bars, businesses and hotels.

* Bike paths for the Cedar Lake trail, which goes to the Chain of Lakes connections.

* New pedestrian bridges will link the stadium to downtown and the warehouse district.

* Nearly every seat will have a view of the downtown skyline.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Having a major league sports franchise is almost as important as having a Fortune 500 company located in your city or metro area. Cities bend over for both, which I don't necessarily agree with. However, I would not want to see the Twins, Wild, Vikings, or the T-Wolves leave for the simple fact that I like having the options. Therefore, I'm willing to pay and as a resident of Minneapolis, I'm happy that the new Twins stadium will be opening in 2010.

Downtown Minneapolis can expect nothing but good things from having a new stadium.

* A new transit hub under the stadium that will connect the Hiawatha light-rail line and North Star commuter line.

* Between 3,000 and 5,000 units of housing are planned around the stadium

* New shops, bars, businesses and hotels.

* Bike paths for the Cedar Lake trail, which goes to the Chain of Lakes connections.

* New pedestrian bridges will link the stadium to downtown and the warehouse district.

* Nearly every seat will have a view of the downtown skyline.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In our case we(Memphis) it was a great idea for our city to invest in the Grizzlies. We built a new stadium in the middle of the entertainment district in south downtown. But the problems that we now have could have been avoided if it weren't for mismanagement. The garage for the FedExForum was a level short of the requirements that the state had wanted and there was no bus terminal. So now we(the citizens of Memphis) have to pay the state back and the buses have to unload out in the front, which is dangerous as I almost got ran over by one.

In all its great to invest but only if there is an interest and prospect. If not you might as well be gambling.

Oh and yes stadiums do cause redevelopement, Brian Davis who will be the owner of the Grizzlies is wanting to spend millions in redeveloping the area around the Forum. Now if we could just get a hockey team.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

^ I know several major league franchises now use them, but PSLs aren't the best answer either. Having fans committed to paying for their seats for several years is a bad idea, especially if the organization can't put a descent team on the field. What happens when the so-called fans want out of their obligation? Also, if several thousand seats go unsold wouldn't any fan be able to buy season tickets without paying for a PSL?

I'm also curious to know if whether or not PSL holders have secured tickets to playoff games. If not, then why should fans be stuck paying fees for the right to buy season tickets?

Link to comment
Share on other sites


^ There are a lot of profitable businesses in this country and they still seek capital improvements at taxpayers' expense.

I know I won't complain once the new Twins stadium is built in Minneapolis. I and every other taxpayer in the city will have access to a new stadium, a new transit hub, new bike trails, new neighborhoods, new businesses, more shopping, more nightlife etc... I wouldn't consider this a bad investment.

Also, not one person can say the Metrodome here in Minneapolis was a bad investment. It has been home to 3 teams (5 for a short period of time) since the early 80s. It has hosted 2 World Series, a Super Bowl, a MLB All-Star game, 2 Final Four tournaments, 6 regionals for the Final Four, large concerts, religious events and several cultural celebrations. These events have brought in billions for the Twin Cities area. The only problem with the Dome was that it was surrounded by several parking lots, most of which have recently been developed. Unlike the Metrodome, the new Twins stadium won't be surrounded by parking lots.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...
Is it good policy for a city to invest tax money in building stadiums and arenas for major league sports? Specifically I mean the NFL, NBA, MLB and NHL.

Supporters for these venues always claim these are economic generators for the cities and in many cases they are built in downtowns and center cities in hopes they will bring some kind of revival in street life and build an urban fabric that people will want to visit and live in. So the question is, do they accomplish this goal or do they amount to little more than corporate welfare?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.